Articles & News About Jobs & Employment

Employment Law: Dismissals For Incapability & Other Topics

Incapability Dismissals

Contrary to popular belief ?ill health? is a potentially fair reason for dismissal since it relates to the employee?s capability to perform the work that they were employed to do. However, in the context of incapability dismissals, the Employment Tribunal will scrutinise the procedures followed by the employer prior to termination, in order to determine whether the decision to dismiss was reasonable in the circumstances. A ?reasonable? employer would normally be expected to consider all the relevant medical evidence, consult with the employee and consider whether there are any steps that could be taken to assist the employee in returning to work. (Employers should also be mindful of the disability discrimination legislation and the need to make reasonable adjustments.)

But what if the employee?s ill-health was caused by the employer in the first place? Should this be taken into account when deciding whether the employee?s dismissal was reasonable?

This question was recently addressed by the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) in the case of Royal Bank of Scotland Plc v McAdie (2006).

The Facts

Ms McAdie went off sick with work-related stress following her employer?s failure to adequately address her grievances and the intimidating manner in which the process had been handled. After 9 months? absence, Ms McAdie was referred to an occupational health doctor who diagnosed ?severe adjustment disorder, secondary to alleged work-place issues, including harassment?. The doctor expressed doubt that the condition could be treated due to the depth of ill-feeling held by Ms McAdie and concluded that a return to work appeared impossible. Following this report, Ms McAdie was dismissed on grounds of incapability. She subsequently brought a claim for unfair dismissal.

The Employment Tribunal initially upheld her claim, finding that her ill-health had been caused by the manner in which the Bank had dealt with her grievance and that this was crucial in determining the fairness of the dismissal. In the Tribunal?s opinion ?no reasonable employer would have dismissed in these circumstances, because no reasonable employer would have found themselves in these circumstances. A reasonable employer would have investigated the matter properly at an early stage.?

EAT?s Decision

However, the EAT overturned this decision. In their view, the fact that an employer may have caused the incapacity did not mean that it could never effect a fair dismissal. Whilst the cause of an employee?s illness was a factor to be taken into consideration, the focus must always be on the reasonableness of the employer?s actions in the circumstances that existed at the time of the proposed dismissal ? not whether the employer should have got itself into those circumstances in the first place.

In the present case, the medical evidence was very clear and the simple fact was that there was no alternative to dismissal. The Bank?s decision could not therefore be said to be unreasonable. The appeal was allowed and the claim dismissed.

Comment

The case of McAdie serves as a useful reminder of the dividing line between unfair dismissal claims and personal injury claims. Save in the context of discrimination cases, the Employment Tribunal has no jurisdiction to hear claims for personal injury. The appropriate course of action for an employee who suffers injury (physical or mental) as a result of a breach of duty by their employer, is to bring a personal injury claim in the civil courts. However, this will require the employee to show that the injury suffered was reasonably foreseeable and this can prove to be a significant hurdle, particularly in ?work-related stress? cases.

AND IN OTHER NEWS?

Flexible Working Extended to Carers

The Government has published the Flexible Working (Eligibility, Complaints and Remedies) (Amendment) Regulations 2006, which extend the right to request flexible working to certain carers of adults. The Regulations will come into force on the 6 April 2007 and will extend the right to request flexible working to employees who are, or expect to be, caring for a person who is over the age of 18 and in need of care, and who is either: married to, the partner of, or the civil partner of the employee; a relative of the employee; or living at the same address as the employee. The right is subject to a qualifying period of 26 weeks continuous employment.

Disability by Association

Carers of disabled people may acquire further legal rights following the referral of Attridge Law v Coleman to the European Court of Justice. Although most discrimination legislation protects employees from detrimental treatment on the grounds that they associate with someone in a protected group (e.g. a white employee dismissed for marrying a black person), the same does not apply to the Disability Discrimination Act 1995 (DDA).

On the face of it, the DDA only applies if the employee themselves are a ?disabled person?. The issue before the ECJ is whether the DDA should be given a wider interpretation so as to prohibit discrimination of an able bodied employee on the grounds of their association with a disabled person. If the claimant?s case is upheld, the scope of the DDA will be significantly extended.

Tim Davies http://employment.michelmores.com/pages/team.asp is an Associate Solicitor at Michelmores Solicitors http://employment.michelmores.com in the Employment Law Department. Contact Tim on tjd@michelmores.com

Other Article Sites

findabook.com  moneycd.info  a-mortgage.info   about-lemon-laws.info  aboutstudentloans.info
all-about-publishing.info  auctions-articles.info  bestcollege-university.com  bestispconnection.com
biblefolder.com  blogger-website.com  books-used.info  brokers-guide.info  buywindows.info  cable-dsl.info
career-miner.com  carpel-tunnel.info  cashinaflash.info  cashloanreviews.info  casinobell.com  chat-house.info
clearmycredit.info  collegeloantips.info  crones.info  depression-articles.info   dirnic.net  dishguides.info
divers-below.com  expodog.info   financewizz.com  fire-insurance.info  getgood.info  handleit.net   it-idea.info
health-supplies.info  hosting-right.com  insidealert.com  insurance-facts.info  jobs-employment.info
justgood.info  lookgold.net   lowcost-travel.info  money-source.info  myhostzone.info  numisblog.com
peoplesearchfinder.info  pr-articles.info  realeas.com   refinancing-guides.info  spyware-remove.info
telelot.info  the-law.info   toppaid.info  travel-deals.info  travelcorrect.com  wedding-guide-site.com
your-blog.info  your-credit.info

How To Build A Successful Freelance Editorial Career
In the current job market, many editorial freelancers have turned to freelance work as a matter of survival. I receive many queries from applicants regarding this part of the market.

Career Fair for Military Veterans and Military Spouses Coming to Indianapolis on March 6
The military-to-civilian recruiting firm RecruitMilitary will present a free hiring event for job seekers who have military backgrounds in Indianapolis on Thursday, March 6. This event, the RecruitMilitary Career Fair, will take place from 11 a.m. until 3 p.m. at the Indiana Convention Center and RCA Dome. RecruitMilitary urges all job seekers who have military backgrounds to attend -- veterans who already have civilian work experience, men and women who are transitioning from active duty to civilian life, members of the National Guard and reserves, and military spouses.

Work Less, Earn More As An Infoproduct Publisher
There's no doubt, publishing information products to sell online is a thriving, exciting and very rewarding business.For many though, the product development and marketing curve simply seems too steep.

Pediatric Occupational Therapist Jobs
When I got my Master's in Occupational Therapy with a concentration on pediatrics I was so excited to look for pediatric occupational therapist jobs. I knew that the internet was going to be a terrific resource for jobs and because I was so young I had the ability to move where the work was located. For me the main issue was what type of facility did I want to work in. Many jobs are located in hospitals and believe it or not I am not a big fan of hospitals.

Master P Changes Name to P. Miller to Prove to Young Hip-Hop Artists That They're Not Limited to Just One Career
Successful businessman and entrepreneur Percy Miller has officially changed his name to P. Miller and will no longer respond to the name "Master P."

Why Low Carb Diets Work
You just got home, it is about 4 or 5 pm, dinner is hours away, you?ve decided to reduce the carbohydrate consumption in your diet, now what? What are you going to do? The chips, candy, and other carb-laden munchies are handy and sound good but are they? You know better. You should really aim for a low carb snack, high protein, healthy snack. You really need something to keep you satisfied until the next the evening meal. This times need to already planned out so that you don't start scurring to find something tasty with a high-carb content. There are many sorts of low carb diets on the market and many of them plan for such a time that I just fore mentioned. You menu plan should consist of all that is to be consumed for the entire week (or ...

Weight Loss Doesnt Work
Your brain has this really interesting system that is kind of like a search engine on the internet. It is called your RAS for short.

Work At Home Opportunities - Ignore Failure
Because failing at a task makes us sad with feelings of unworthiness, many people choose not to take any risk. These individuals live their lives in quiet desperation because they have such high aspirations for their lives. The problem is these individuals are paralyzed by fear, they can't live or do what they really want because they are afraid to fail.

Career Success: Don't Be Caught With Your Pants Down
Do you want to know how to jump-start your professional career? Or, are you already in the trenches trying to be a high performer and wanting to make a quantum lead to the next stage of your career? Or, because of downsizings or reorganizations, you feel like you are paddling faster and faster but seem to be getting nowhere? Find out how to monitor your changing environment so you won't be caught with your pants down.Visualize your career environment as one huge jigsaw puzzle.

Cant You See Im Working?
For many working parents, telecommuting or a home business may seem like the answer to your prayers. You want to have more time with your kids and greater flexibility, so you take the leap, install a second phone line, and set up a computer in the dining room.

You Can?t Get Fit At Work, Can You?
You better believe you can.

Career Change Nurse Overseas
If you are looking for a career change in nursing then you should consider nursing overseas. Countries around the world are experiencing an acute nursing shortage which has created opportunities for nurses to refresh their nursing careers by going abroad to fill vacancies in other countries either short term or long term.

Simple Solutions To Today's Harder Life - Work Less, Earn More
This week I was punching around the radio dial and happened upon a talk show host who summed up today's challenging life in a single sentence. He said, "I'm absolutely convinced, life has gotten a lot harder in the last five years."

Business Skills Training Can Help You Succeed in Your Career
New Horizons Learning Centers offers a complete, simplified learning solution that focuses on knowledge transfer, retention and skills development. Our training programs are based on the market's needs. With our clients' input, we tailor our training programs to the needs of the industry, giving our students a distinct advantage. You will be trained and prepared to pass the industry certifications required by employers, setting you apart from the competition.

Work From Home Opportunities
Many more people are turning toward the internet to find themselves a work from home opportunity. With so much information available on the internet it opens doors for those who want to work from home and give up the mundane life of travelling to and from a job every day.